Cookie Dough Store Nyc

Cookie Dough Store Nyc

Remember mom letting you taste cookie dough when you were young? Ah! That was the best part of helping with the baking! Gooey on the Inside is a cookie dough store in NYC that gives you a chance to relive those moments in the most glorious of ways.

The tastiest cookie

Ours is a story about a cookie loving emotional eater from Canada who was obsessed with the idea of creating the perfect cookie and cookie dough. She had the crazy idea of perfecting the gooey cookie, one that is not only awesomely crispy around the edges but also filled with gooey goodness on the inside. After countless trials and batches of cookies, the perfect ooey-gooey cookie was born.  

And so the journey began: starting from a compact Chelsea apartment kitchen to our first cookie dough store in NYC. Kafi is passionate about cookies, and this passion leads her to not only recreate these classics but to do it in a way that can bring a smile on every cookie dough lover’s face. We have sampled various flavors, and ingredients to offer you a unique take on these time-honored classics.     

What makes your cookie dough unique?

There are many reasons why our cookie dough is the best, but the main two are:

  • We only use high-quality ingredients – quality is of the utmost importance with us. That is why we have invested in quality ingredients for our cookie dough. Every constituent has been carefully sampled and used in multiple trial batches to ensure that it has what it takes to create the best cookie dough.
  • All our ingredients are natural – we do not use any preservatives or anything artificial in our cookie dough recipes. As a small store, we have the luxury of making a fresh dough that has no raw flour in every order. This is a luxury we do not take for granted. Our mixture is also pasteurized, significantly reducing your chances of getting any food-related illnesses.    

Are you a cookie dough fan? You are definitely in the right place! Welcome to our store where it’s all about you. Here you get fantastic safe to eat cookie dough in different flavors to fit your unique tastes. 

Where to find the best cookie store

We are currently at 163 Chrystie Street, New York. At our NYC store, you get to enjoy quality personalized customer experience and meet Kafi, who is always available, making sure you get the best. Add that to the variety of cookie dough creations, ooey-gooey cookies, cookie bites, jars, and ice cream, and you are in cookie heaven.

We have partnered with various on-demand delivery services in the city to get our offers to you quickly. You can get Gooey on the Inside goodies on Seamless, Doordash, Postmates, Uber Eats, Grubhub,, and Eat24. You can also pick up at the storefront by calling us on 646-972-0409 and placing your pre-order for pick-up later! We love it when you pay us a visit, won’t you stop by our cookie dough store in NYC today?

Cookie Dough Store Nyc
Gooey on The Inside Cookies
+1 646-972-0409
Cookie Dough Store Nyc
163 Chrystie Street
New York NY 10002

View Larger Map

We welcome your comments!